I just made reservations for end of Jan. I requested the Spas even though they are older. There is someone here that owns in that area and he said they have been updated (new carpet, linens etc). I wanted to be in a 2 storey building, and I will have a family of 8, so I wanted the larger rooms.
I, too, read a terrible review just before we decided on the Vistana. *shrug*. I figure no place will get 100%positive....I'm confident it will be fine. If we get a bad room, I'll just be really loud until they move us to a better room. I'm really not anticipating a problem though.
BTW, we will be there for 8 days and only 3 of those days will be in the parks.....so we will be spending A LOT of time around the resort. No place else I looked into seemed to have the amenities that Vistana offered for the price.
Did you read that guys review about not being able to get into his room after arriving late at night with his family? Hopefully if his letter got to the right people, that experience won't be repeated.
Wish I could say I've been there and it's awesome, but I *can* say I'm fairly confident that the odds are pretty darn good for having a great time at the Vistana.