I was to Bermuda off the Magic in 2018. I had also visited the island for a week back in 2012.
DH and I went on our on to Horseshoe Bay Beach on our own. Plenty of shuttles running back and forth all day, very easy. Chair and Umbrella rentals available, plus bathrooms and snack bar (and regular bar for cocktails).
If you go make you head down beach towards the big rocks. See photos
We did an island tour that went to Lighthouse, Hamilton and St. George. It was a long Day but a good tour.
There is also a lot to do where the ship docks. There is a fort there and shops etc.
I am sure you will get more advice from others. Have a fantastic cruise.
I will be on a cruise this November out of NYC stopping in Bermuda, Tortola and ending in San Juan. I can’t wait to visit Bermuda again.

