Rumors that Disney is in negotiations to sell Star Wars back to George Lucas!

[mdmost]

I doubt it, they won’t treat her character like that as they have too much respect for her.

They will likely have her accomplish all the great things that the deadbeat Luke wasn’t able to accomplish.

 

[nancipants]

So here's a fun thing you can do: Just imagine this completely made-up character however you want. If you want to end his story after Jedi, go for it.

Yup. I wanted Rey to be Luke’s daughter and that didn’t happen so instead of complaining on the internet I wrote three books instead.

 

[FCDub]

Yup. I wanted Rey to be Luke’s daughter and that didn’t happen so instead of complaining on the internet I wrote three books instead.

Cool! That's great, and a much more productive use of your time – truly.

 

[ttintagel]

My SW rankings:

1. A New Hope
2. The Empire Strikes Back
3. Return of the Jedi
4. The Last Jedi
5. The Phantom Menace
6. The Force Awakens
7. Revenge of the Sith
8. Attack of the Clones
9. The Rise of Skywalker
10. Solo
11. Rogue One

6 and 7 could be a tie. Basically, my headcanon includes just the numbered films and not the standalones or any of the TV shows. (If The Mandalorian had ended with the first season, it would have been the exception.)

Demographics: American, woman, a little too young when A New Hope came out but saw the rest of them in their first theatrical run.

 

[PolymerSkywalker]

Your top 3 are pretty close to being correct imho, but #4 is way the heck off.

 

[TraderStitch]

Gotta switch 11 and 4. Rogue One was so good.

 

[PolymerSkywalker]

Rogue one was the best Disney Star Wars movie by a large margin.

Switch 4 with 11, and you are getting really close to accurate imho.

 

[leiaorgana]

Not being funny or anything but how can you tell people that their personal rankings / opinions aren’t “accurate”? Accurate to who? It’s all subjective. Just not accurate in your eyes? I don’t agree with some of your rankings but I’m not going to tell you that your own personal ranking is wrong or not accurate. That’s just silly. Again not arguing. I just think what you’re saying is badly phrased since it’s other people’s personal opinions on the matter. I personally think having Rogue One at the bottom is absolute blasphemy since in my eyes it’s one of the best things that’s been put out in years but I’m not going to tell that poster that their opinion is wrong or inaccurate about it because that’s how they view it.

 

[PolymerSkywalker]

Accurate in my eyes, jeez I thought that was pretty darn clear. This is a discussion board where you know , people discuss their opinions. Like your opinion that Rey is incredible, inspiring, and well done in film……basically the bestest ever! While I am thinking she is a Mary Sue with no character arc who has almost no flaws so is therefore really hard to identify with and like as a character.

No one’s opinion is wrong of course, except yours about Rey that is definitely wrong

 

[irlandaise]

Accurate in my eyes, jeez I thought that was pretty darn clear. This is a discussion board where you know , people discuss their opinions.

"Accurate" and "correct" are terms one applies to facts, not opinions. Ttintagel's list is neither incorrect nor inaccurate, so saying that it is comes across as dismissive of her opinion--"badly phrased" as leiaorgana said.

If you want to disagree with someone's subjective rankings, then say "I disagree."

 

[PolymerSkywalker]

"Accurate" and "correct" are terms one applies to facts, not opinions. Ttintagel's list is neither incorrect nor inaccurate, so saying that it is comes across as dismissive of her opinion--"badly phrased" as leiaorgana said.

If you want to disagree with someone's subjective rankings, then say "I disagree."

How about you do you, and stop telling me your opinion on the “correct” way to give an “accurate” depiction of my opinion?

 

[leiaorgana]

No one’s opinion is wrong of course, except yours about Rey that is definitely wrong

It’s funny you should say that because I saw “Rey” today when strolling through Batuu and told her PolymerSkywalker was her biggest fan and couldn’t wait to see her next movie (jk, jk)

I did happen to see Kylo and Mando again today though so that was good.

 

[mdmost]

It’s funny you should say that because I saw “Rey” today when strolling through Batuu and told her PolymerSkywalker was her biggest fan and couldn’t way to see her next movie (jk, jk)

I did happen to see Kylo and Mando again today though so that was good.

You didn't scream at Rey how she was a Mary Sue?

 

[PolymerSkywalker]

You didn't scream at Rey how she was a Mary Sue?

She knows it, you don’t really have to tell her

 

[leiaorgana]

You didn't scream at Rey how she was a Mary Sue?

I think she thought I was saying “I love R2 too”

 

[mdmost]

I think she thought I was saying “I love R2 too”

Or did she think you were saying "you ruined my childhood"?

 

[nancipants]

It’s funny you should say that because I saw “Rey” today when strolling through Batuu and told her PolymerSkywalker was her biggest fan and couldn’t wait to see her next movie (jk, jk)

I did happen to see Kylo and Mando again today though so that was good.

One day I’ll see Mando.

 

[ttintagel]

How about you do you, and stop telling me your opinion on the “correct” way to give an “accurate” depiction of my opinion?

Nah, words actually do have meanings.

 

[leiaorgana]

One day I’ll see Mando.

Honestly, both times this week were by complete chance and I wasn’t even looking for him. Today was after drunk piloting the Falcon on a totally legitimate business trip for Hondo after a few drinks at Oga’s

 

[irlandaise]

How about you do you, and stop telling me your opinion on the “correct” way to give an “accurate” depiction of my opinion?

Giving your opinion of which SW movies are the best is fine. Telling someone else that their opinion is wrong is not fine.