I agree with Pammy. We thought the food was very good as well but a step below excellent. The drinks were ice cold though and we appreciated that after a long August day. It's a pretty solid choice.
We love Paradiso 37, one of favorites and it's consistently good. I love their shrimp and jicama salad which is not a step below excellent, it is excellent. I have a review with photos on my website if you'd like to check it out. It is from the spring but we were just there this past Saturday night and ordered the same thing plus another entree which I have yet to post. My dh had the salmon on Saturday and that was excellent as well. The spinach dip this trip was better than I remembered it too.
Last time we went was in Dec. I am very picky and still had a great meal (chicken sandwich and fries) We plan on going back for either drinks and apps or dinner in March. The menu has changed since opening but is still good!
I actually posted on another thread that they don't take the DDP however I looked on the official WDW website under that restaurant and it said they do take it.