Replacement Windows...Anderson or Pella

etwinchester

DIS Veteran
Joined
Aug 6, 2002
Messages
1,395
We are looking to get some replacement windows and have quotes for Anderson & Pella windows.

Does anyone have any experiences to share with me? I've heard of Anderson (Home Depot) but we also checked out Lowes and they carry Pella, which I've never heard of.
 
I used to work in that industry - for Marvin. Both Andersen and Pella are excellent companies with good products (as is Marvin). I wouldn't hesitate to buy a window from any of those three manufacturers.
 
we've had both! Pella at our last house, Anderson on our new to us house! Both are excellent - can't lose, go with whichever one is less!!
 

ok, thanks. The Andersons are cheaper but the Pella's have one more made for log homes (alum on outside and wood on inside so you can paint or stain that side).
 
We need to replace a lot of our Anderson windows. They are 14 years old and moisture formed inside them and the window looks fogged up. I noticed it on our patio door windows last weekend.

We contacted Anderson and they said their warranty is 10 years.
 
OhMari said:
We need to replace a lot of our Anderson windows. They are 14 years old and moisture formed inside them and the window looks fogged up. I noticed it on our patio door windows last weekend.

We contacted Anderson and they said their warranty is 10 years.

That is pretty common for windows. The dual pane sealant won't last forever and eventually the window needs to be replaced. Marvin sued their sealant manufactuer (10 years ago or longer now), but replaced all the windows that had faulty sealant (they lost their lawsuit and still stood behind their product, costing them a ton of money, but giving them a great reputation). Check the warrenty, but don't expect dual pane windows to outlast their warrenty forever or for window companies to replace windows after the warrenty expires..
 
crisi said:
That is pretty common for windows. The dual pane sealant won't last forever and eventually the window needs to be replaced.


Pella and Anderson both have a 20 year warranty against seal failure on their sealed glass. The BIG difference is that Pella does not prorate their warranty.
The fully transferable warranty on sealed glass in Pella windows is 100% for 20 years.
 
Bob NC said:
Pella and Anderson both have a 20 year warranty against seal failure on their sealed glass. The BIG difference is that Pella does not prorate their warranty.
The fully transferable warranty on sealed glass in Pella windows is 100% for 20 years.

From what I know (and my industry knowledge is a little dated now) that is a BIG PLUS for Pella. As I said, seal failure is pretty common - or it was when I was in the window industry.
 
We have the Anderson Renewals. We got them almost 2 years and and really like them.
 
We had Andersen installed when we built our home 7 years ago. We upgraded from the entry-level Andersen windows, but I do not know what the model is. They are double pane, low e, vinyl clad exterior, wood stained interior.

Within 2 years, 4 of my 5 circle tops developed the spots between the windows. Dealing with Customer Service and the local rep was a nightmare! (They told me that the reps in my area were "in transition". Translation: The consumer was left to fend for him/herself.) After 4 MONTHS of frustration - phone calls, no response, more calls, still no response. I was sent on a wild goose chase when I finally got to speak to a human being. FINALLY, my windows got replaced - IN JANUARY!!!

Soon after that episode, the seal in my fifth circle top went...Another 3 MONTHS of headaches...but I finally got it replaced too. (Andersen will provide replacement GLASS - NOT LABOR - after a certain period of time. They made it VERY CLEAR to me that they were covering the labor as a "Good Will' gesture. "Good Will"??...my eye! They obviously had a manufacturing defect present in the lot that produced ALL 5 of my identical windows!

I just noticed that one of my casement windows has spots. NO WAY am I dealing with them again! I will live with the spots and SMILE all the way to the Pella retailer when it's time to replace my windows.

Thanks for letting me "vent". As you can tell, this is a "hot topic" for me. Just goes to show you that you can produce a decent quality product and have a good reputation, but if you don't handle your customer with the proper respect, you will lose them.

What's that phrase..."Satisfy one person and they'll tell 3(?) people...Tick them off, and they'll tell 20..." I think I just told more than 20 with this post!
 
Pella!!!! I know several people that have them. We had them installed in our old house and loved them.
 
We have Harvey replacement windows put in 2 years ago. What a difference in our heating bill. We are very pleased with them.

Jean
 
We have Anderson right now, but have had Pella in the past... in fact I think our newer front door is a Pella.

I've not had a problem.
 
Home Depot also carries replacements that have the vinal outside & wood inside. We just ordered the first half to get rid of the M&W windows that have been foggy forever. Don't get those whatever you do.
 
This is a great thread with tons of good info. Does anyone know if the Pella windows in the hardward stores are the same quality as those if you went to a Pella rep. We need new windows very bad. But, I don't even know where to start on what quality we need. Does anyone have ideas on what questions you should ask. Many thanks!
 
I've had a very bad experience with my Pella Architect Series windows and doors installed throughout my home in 1995. I would NOT recommend using Pella. Please check out this website, detailing the various window and door failures/defects I have experienced with Pella: onlinelitigationdiscovery.com\ Please feel free to share your similar experiences with Pella on my website. Thanks.
 
We have Harvey windows too. Had them put in about 7-8 years ago. We're very happy with them.
 


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom