rate in order best to worst, Disney resorts you've stayed at

[Got Quattro?]

Beach Club
Wilderness Lodge
Contemp Resort
Poly
Port Orleans FQ
Animal Kingdom
C Beach Resort

 

[rcraw45425]

GF
YC
CR
WL
Poly
Swan

 

[disneyworld!]

YC CL - the best resort!!!!

BC CL & BC - love the decor and location!! pool great

BWV 1 BR. - great space and location!!!

WL - My favorite old stand by!!

BWI DCL - great Location!!

Swan Ex Suite - this 3 br. was huge!! great views and location

CBR - even after the above...I found this resort awesome!

P0LY CL hawaii - you could'nt pay me enough to go back!

 

[DisneyPhD]

Ok I will bite, so early in the game

My list is very simlar to yours.

Beach Club (Villas)
Yaht Club
Animal Kingdom Lodge
Poly
Wilderness Lodge
Dixie Landings (it was back then!)
Corando Springs
POFQ
Caribian Beach

 

[kelscross]

Poly
ASMO
ASMU
Pop
CBR

 

[J.C.&ALI'SMOM]

1. Polynesian
2. Contemporary
3. Grand Floridian
4. Swan
5. Dolphin

 

[OCDdisneynut]

Swan FUN/UPSCALE
AKL DIFFERENT/GREAT FOOD
POR BEAUTIFUL/RELAXING
Not really any comparison to the top 3:
ASMu

 

[MommyBoo!]

CR
Poly

 

[weluvpluto]

Poly
WL
POR
POFQ
CSR
CBR
ASSp

 

[bridgettesmom]

1. POLY
2. POR
3. Dolphin
4. POFQ
5. Contemporary
6. POP
7. AKL
8. ASMU

 

[pinkpiglettlover]

GF
WL
AKL
Swan
CR
CBR

 

[Buttercup Roberts]

Favorite: Animal Kingdom Lodge
Ft. Wilderness Cabins
Boardwalk Villas
Port Orleans French Quarter
Villas at Wilderness Lodge
Dixie Landings / aka PO Riverisde
Ft. Wilderness in a tent
All Star Music
Least Favorite: All Star Movies

And boy, the Swolphin is getting slammed on this thread, and so is the Caribbean Beach Resort! Maybe they just can't compete with the great ones on the list. I'd still take them over a hotel off site!

 

[skiwee1]

Poly
CBR
WL

 

[Ladyhawke10]

All time favorite--Grand Floridian

Animal Kingdom Lodge (deluxe savannah view)

Boardwalk Inn

Beach Club (concierge/ courtyard view)

Wilderness Lodge (concierge/ castle view)

Port Orleans French Quarter

Yacht Club (water view)

Swan (water view)

Port Orleans Riverside (mansions)

 

[BelleChick]

Wl
Por
Pof
Csr
Cbr
Asm

 

[Keokagal]

I have only been 4 x's. April and July we are trying AKL and CSR and Dolphin again.

Dolphin (snuck over for 3 nites away from ASSp, softball trip, left the girls w the chaperones)
CBR our first trip to WDW so was magical every minute as nothing else compared at that point.
Dixie Landings/POR
ASSp loathe it there, filthy

Getting sooooo excited!!!

 

[kandeebunny]

CBR
BWV
CR
Swan
Dolphin

I live in NE on the ocean so BC and YC never appealed to me I don't want to feel like I am at home on vacation. GF doesn't fit us well nor does Poly.

We are trying SoG this trip so we shall see!

 

[Nolcrest]

POR
WL
POFQ
Wilderness Home
CBR
CR

 

[mom23guys2]

1. AKL Our favorite- just returned from a week there. We always try to stay at least a few nights here on every trip.
2. Beach Club
3. Poly
4. Swan
5. POR
6. Dolphin- Only stay once on Club level before refurbishing
7. CSR
8. ASMo- Best of the All-Stars
9. ASSp
10. ASMu- Hated it.

I really dislike the All-Stars but they are okay if you just need a place to sleep on Disney Property. They are loud and the rooms are noisy. You can hear your neighbor's every word.

 

[joliesmom]

1. AKL
2. Contemporary
3. SOG
4. Dixie Landings
5. Poly
6. ASMovies