Rain cover for my P3 stroller: should I buy the zip-on or a regular stroller cover?

[Disneyfriend]

We're gearing up for our WDW trip this September, and will probably take our P3 stroller for the baby. I want to get a rain cover for the stroller, and was wondering whether to get a generic rain cover like this:

Generic Rain Cover

or a rain cover specifically made to zip into a P3 like this:

P3 Zippered Rain Cover

Has anybody out there used either one, and can you give me any feedback about it? Thanks very much!

Disneyfriend

 

[diselderm]

I used a generic cover for my P3 last December and it worked fine.

 

[MichelleChell]

I'm using a poncho.

 

[aroyer]

I actually bought a Combi rain cover from Babies R Us this week and it fits very nicely on my P3. And it was half the price of the Peg Perego rain cover.

 

[2poohbears]

I used these on our umbrella strollers this year and they worked great. I really like the side mesh vents---allows the boys to get some air but they don't get wet. I have one without the vents for my double stroller and I think they get hot with that one.
http://www.toysrus.com/product/inde...over&kw=stroller+rain+cover&parentPage=search

 

[lovedvc]

I always purchase a few cheap clear ponchos at Walmart and they work great at keeping the strollers dry.

 

[mello]

I'm using a poncho.

Worked great!