I've eaten at both. Agree that if you want to stay in the park, Mama Melrose is good. We are going again in September.
We did a walk-up to Raglan Road in March and were seated in the very back room. We could hear the entertainment, but couldn't see it -- that was a big disappointment.
I got the Ain't No Bleedin Chowder and just fell in love!!! Agree the food is excellent; however, my enjoyment would have been greater had we been seated in the main room.