Question about Tinker Bell Disney Story Doll – Peter Pan – 10"

[cobright]

Not exactly sure if this is correct forum but it seems the best fit.

I need to replace the Tinkerbell doll from the "Tinker Bell Disney Story Doll" set (disney store item no. 460025165137). The set is brand new but the poor pixie was placed under a water bottle on the dash of my car and the water focused the sun onto the side of her head and ... it's not a good look. The owner of the doll is very sweet and takes full responsibility, but I would like to replace it. That said, I notice in the online Disney Store there is a less expensive set that appears to have the same doll but without quite so many accessories. That would be: "Tinker Bell Classic Doll – Peter Pan – 10'' (disney store item no. 460012300251).
and

This seems like it is the exact same doll, but I can't really be certain. I have a real issue with face blindness, and it's not available in the actual stores to look at in person. If anyone has seen both and can comment, or even just look at these two pics and give an opinion on if they are the same doll, I would be thankful. The wings seem more blue in the larger set and her dress is a more complex pattern, but the wings may just be a difference in lighting...

It's a pretty low stakes issue either way, it's about a $15 difference between the two sets but I would rather not buy a whole new set just to throw half of it away.

Thanks!

 

[DodgerGirl]

If you go to JCPenney they have a Tinker Bell doll that has fluttering wings when you press her back. And that's the doll my mother got for Christmas and she uses it as a Christmas tree topper. But you should go on Disney Store and see if they have the same doll for sale and you can buy one as a replacement
Glad to be helpful

 

[AprilsZoo]

Not exactly sure if this is correct forum but it seems the best fit.

I need to replace the Tinkerbell doll from the "Tinker Bell Disney Story Doll" set (disney store item no. 460025165137). The set is brand new but the poor pixie was placed under a water bottle on the dash of my car and the water focused the sun onto the side of her head and ... it's not a good look. The owner of the doll is very sweet and takes full responsibility, but I would like to replace it. That said, I notice in the online Disney Store there is a less expensive set that appears to have the same doll but without quite so many accessories. That would be: "Tinker Bell Classic Doll – Peter Pan – 10'' (disney store item no. 460012300251).
View attachment 982754 and View attachment 982757

This seems like it is the exact same doll, but I can't really be certain. I have a real issue with face blindness, and it's not available in the actual stores to look at in person. If anyone has seen both and can comment, or even just look at these two pics and give an opinion on if they are the same doll, I would be thankful. The wings seem more blue in the larger set and her dress is a more complex pattern, but the wings may just be a difference in lighting...

It's a pretty low stakes issue either way, it's about a $15 difference between the two sets but I would rather not buy a whole new set just to throw half of it away.

Thanks!

It looks like the same doll to me. It would be worth looking for the specs, or details on the product pages for each play set, just to be sure that the dolls are the same size.
Otherwise, they look exactly the same to me. I don’t see any difference in the dress or the wings, that isn’t explained by the differences in photography.
Good luck.