We rented in the spring of 2003. I was nervous about it, but frankly, it was a truly wonderful experience!
We received the same treatement as a DVC member. Our keycard gave us the discounts, and we got the "welcome home" as soon as we entered the premises.
For this year's trip, we were ready to rent again. But, friends gave us an early Christmas present. (We have great friends!) We're pretty determined that next time we will be using our own points.
Renting DVC is a great opportunity to experience the conveniences of staying onsite and immersing yourself fully in The World. I don't think we could go back to an offsite hotel, so be forewarned that renting could be hazardous in ways you never anticipated.
j