I am happy to read that you enjoyed San Angel. We had dinner there a few years ago and I admit that I was very disappointed. We are trying it again this year for lunch hoping for a better experience. Your husband's pork dish looked wonderful!
We have avoided Mama Melrose's due to the bad reviews (and our love of Primetime and Brown Derby), but those pictures make it definitely look worth a trip! Thanks!!
Sounds like a nice last lunch and both meals looked really good!!
Thank you for taking the time to write up your food report as it was so nice to hear the varying opinions from so many people in your family!!
Looking forward to your trip report!!
I think your reviews of Mama Melrose and San Angel Inn were spot on! I always get the wood grilled chicken at MM and I love the hazlenut cheesecake so much I emailed Disney for the recipe!!!!! And your comments about why you believe San Angel gets bad reviews? I couldn't agree more - it's closer to authentic Mexican than most of us are used to.
Thanks so much for sharing your reviews, I have really enjoyed them. I love the El Pirata Y el Perico restaurant but it has only been open once in all the times we have been! Sounds like the San Angel Inn is one to add to the list.