DH and I went to Hawaii in March/April 2007 and had a fabulous time!! You're going to LOVE it wherever you stay. If you'd like to see our album on Shutterfly, PM me and I'll give you the link.
I'd highly recommend buying the "revealed" guide books -- there is one for each island. I found them to be a life safer for planning the trip. You can seach Kauai + revealed on
amazon and find it. Do the same for the other islands.
We stayed on Oahu, Big Island and spent the most time on Kauai. We loved them all for different reasons. We are not big sunbathers or relaxing on the beach kind of people, so take that into consideration when reading this
Oahu -- we stayed at the Turtle Bay Resort on the North Shore. The thought of staying in Waikiki did not appeal to us, and in fact I didn't want to stay on Oahu at all but DH really wanted to spend a day at Pearl Harbor. So we compromised and stayed on the North Shore which was fantastic. Turtle Bay was MUCH less expensive than Waikiki hotels and beautiful. There are many hiking trails on their property and a secluded beach not far from the resort off one of the trails. We would stay again. Also, if you are a LOST fan they film a lot on the grounds of the resort which is fun. The big things we did on Oahu was spend a day at Pearl Harbor and a driving tour of Waikiki -- we also watched the sunset at the state park off Tantulus drive. The drive along Tantulus was awesome in itself and then the timing worked out that we could watch the sunset from an overlook at the state park. We also went to the Polynesian Cultural Center which was nice, but we wouldn't go a second time.
Big Island -- we stayed at the Hilton Waikeola too, and it was really nice. Be warned - it is HUGE!! Plan an extra 10-15 minutes to get to your car because of walking or waiting for the monorail. We almost missed our whale watching tour because of not allowing extra time. We also spent a day to drive over to the other side of the island to Volcanoes National Park. We stopped and got a picnic lunch and then hiked the Kilauea Iki trail and ate our lunch at the bottom of a crater next to a steam vent -- what a memory!! We also dropped the cash to do the Mauna Kea sunset and stargazing tour. It was AMAZING and I'd spend the $$$ to do it again.
Kauai -- we also stayed at the Hilton, but didn't have the same experience as Katie. It wasn't our favorite hotel of the trip, but it was nice. The room was by far the smallest of the three hotels we stayed in but we didn't spend much time in the room or at the resort for that matter. Maybe a half day a couple times to lounge by the pool. Friends of ours stayed at the Hyatt for their honeymoon and RAVED about it. We just couldn't afford it or Princeville. The location of the Hilton was perfect and looking back, that was most important for us. We did lots of things on Kauai but all were sightseeing and adventure -- zipline tour at Princeville ranch (fantastic!), boat tour of NaPali w/ snorkeling (not the best time of year for snorkeling but we did see lots of dolphins and whales which we didn't expect), couple of hikes in Waimea canyon. We rented a 4WD on Kauai and glad we did -- there were a few places we explored where it was needed. One drive in Waimea canyon was amazing but I forced DH to turn around (which was hard to do!) because it was late in the afternoon, looked like it was going to rain and our cell phones didn't work up there. I was so nervous we were going to get stuck!
As far as restaurants, we went on the recommendations in the revealed books and were not disappointed. Once you decide on which islands, buy the revealed books (or get them from your library). They will help you plan everything!
Let me know if you have any questions or want to see our pics. Have fun!! I'm jealous! I told DH when we were in Hawaii that I wanted to go back for my 50th birthday (12 years!!), and he agreed. I'm already planning what I want to do
