OK looking for opinions

[pintrader]

Please keep in mind that an opinion is not right or wrong it is just someone's opinion.

Put yourself on both sides of this "deal" If you were the recipient of the first group or the giver of the first group and then if you were the recipient of the second group or the second group. What would you feel was a fair exchange if you were on either side of this exchange? Pin 4331: Shopper Minnie - Born to Shop, Silver Jail scene, silver mystery dangle LE 1000. wet paint LE 1000, Pin 2280: World Showcase Millennium Banner Mystery #2 Banner pin LE 1000(?) Pin 2558: WDW Olympic Spirit with Fab Five Pin 3377: Merry Christmas 2000 LE 1000, Pin 3830: WDW Wet Paint Mystery Pin LE 1000, Pin 3888: WDW Black Heritage Celebration 2001 LE 1000, Pin 6242: Pooh with glitter hunny pot LE.

LE1200 Plane Crazy Filmstrip, LE1000 Small World E-ticket.

Again if you were on either side of this what would you feel was the most fair combination you could come up with.

This is like shopping in the WISH book at Christmas time.

 

[Eeyore's Pal]

Not sure if this helps, I ordered the pins according to my opinion of their desirability.

From lowest to highest (hardest to get):

Black Heritage

Born to Shop

Olympic Spirit

Pooh with glitter hunny pot LE

LE1000 Small World E-ticket

World Showcase Millennium Banner Mystery

LE1200 Plane Crazy Filmstrip

Wet Paint

Silver Jail scene

Not sure where these fit; I don't know they as well:
silver mystery dangle
Merry Christmas 2000

 

[shirley 38]

Wow I had to print this out. Beings a pin tradaer for a very long long time this is my opinion.
I am going by what is available on ebay and now much it is going for.
The hardest pins right now to get are Wet Paint and the LE of 1000 Plane crazy pin
These two I think would be a equal trade.

Humm Silver Jail Scene pin is a great pin but more and more are showing up on e-bay. For a trade it would have to be the E-ticket small world.

Banner pin is another one you don't see around too much but it is old. A good trade for this would be another old mystery pin like Silver mystery dangle. This is a old one

Minnie born to shop a very good pin good trader for this is another mystery pin maybe some of the new nightmare pins coming out.

WDW Olympic spirt pin fab five maybe a good trade for the Poohwith glitter hunny pot. Neither one is a hot pin.

Merry Christmas 2000 not a good trade. Black Heritage for get it.
I would trade for anything new with a low LE for either of the above two pins.

Just my opinion no small children or animals hurt.