Official American Idol Season 7: Top 10 to ??

[aprilgail2]

Oh boy..... I was soooo looking forward to David... I hope it gets better.

It didn't! I actually got up and left half way through it, I didn't like that one bit! He is in my bottom 3 this week!! Michael Johns was REALLY good this week! Jason has to go though, he has such a weak voice! I missed Chickeze and Brook this week so I dont know how they did!

 

[gypsydoodlebug]

I'm a huge Brooke White fan, but DANG! Michael Johns rocked it out. I'm buying that on iTunes!

 

[damo]

Yup, they will probably do better on their own. Daughtry vs. Taylor Hicks? Hmmmmmm!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I don't think Taylor Hicks didn't succeed because he won and I don't think Daughtry succeeded because he lost. Other winners have done wonderfully and other losers have done poorly.

 

[marymrg]

Top Two (i.e. songs I will download): David C and Michael

Good: Syesha, Carly, Brooke

Just Ok: David A

Might be in danger: Kristy - she picked the right song, did ok, but Simon said it was good so maybe people will think she is safe?? It was so much better than her other performances though so that will help her

Possible Bottom 3:
Ramielle: Not as good as Carly's version in Hollywood and no where near as good as the original

Jason: Not a good song to choose

Chikezie: Did ok on a very old sounding arrangement

 

[goofinoff]

Yes indeed - it aired just a few months ago. Read all about it on this thread (on page 72 there are instructions for downloading it if you wanna see!)

//end shameless self promotion

OMG!! I saw that one!!! Congratulations! How are you doing? Have you gone back to your "old ways??"

 

[Nancy]

Yes indeed - it aired just a few months ago. Read all about it on this thread (on page 72 there are instructions for downloading it if you wanna see!)

//end shameless self promotion




Love it! I think my bottom three would just be:
1. Not Dave C
2. Not Dave C
3. Not Dave C

How nice of John to get that video set up. I'm going to watch it now because I don't remeber seeing the actual show.

 

[LiLIrishChick63]

I worship at the alter of David Cook!!!!!!!!!!!!!

*joins in*

 

[Robinrs]

C'mon! You gotta share at least one of them!

Not gonna HAPPEN!!

I'm gonna be one downloading Mama this week!!

 

[goofinoff]

I don't think Taylor Hicks didn't succeed because he won and I don't think Daughtry succeeded because he lost. Other winners have done wonderfully and other losers have done poorly.

Oh absolutely! ITA!! I guess it's luck of the draw. I don't think Taylor was main stream enough to be a huge success like a Kelly or Carrie. He definatley can sing but I think he has a target audience.

 

[2bemarried]

I got in over 10 votes for David C

 

[Robinrs]

I'm a huge Brooke White fan, but DANG! Michael Johns rocked it out. I'm buying that on iTunes!

Thanks, honey, check out my OTHER old man, too....

 

[TwinsinCA]

I had to watch it a few times first...

My God. DC is just flat out AMAZING. There is nothing...NOTHING he can't make sound good! He made Michael Freaking JACKSON sound good.

He looked better tonight than ever. When he screams? I love his little sniff thing he has.


The part before the song was hilarious with the baby pictures. "I had a massive skull"

 

[dolphindan1]

Jason-eh, didn't hate it. didn't love it.

Too slow and boring for me....I do like how laid back he is but not so much on stage...it was ok...

Ramille was Blah

Syesha was ok

 

[Mean Queen]

*joins in*

Make some more room at that altar -

 

[MinnieMe87]

Thanks, honey, check out my OTHER old man, too....

One of them has to have a cute brother, right? I'm just sayin'...

 

[LiLIrishChick63]

I had to watch it a few times first...

My God. DC is just flat out AMAZING. There is nothing...NOTHING he can't make sound good! He made Michael Freaking JACKSON sound good.

He looked better tonight than ever. When he screams? I love his little sniff thing he has.


The part before the song was hilarious with the baby pictures. "I had a massive skull"

and i love that he looks AND sounds better every week!!

 

[Robinrs]

I'll bet those dimbulbs in the exec offices are wondering why they hitched their wagons on the wrong David...

 

[dolphindan1]

Haha, sorry I'm a huge Carrie fan and I think that was my favorite performance she did.

Actually my boyfriend gets mad because I think Carrie's version of "Independence Day" is better than Martina McBride's.

Thats a tuff one. Martina has arguably the best voice in country and several other genre's. but Carrie is no slouch either. Carrie may have had a better version but Martina I think is vocally superior.....JMHO

 

[nannerbadnanner]

I'll bet those dimbulbs in the exec offices are wondering why they hitched their wagons on the wrong David...

 

[dolphindan1]

I used to like her. But she starting to bug me in the little videos before the songs.

She has a great voice....but I don't know this song so it's a little hard for me to get into it.

Her vocals are amazing. I just wish I knew the song.

I can hear Simon going "randy! randy!" off camera.

I think out of all the girls in the top 24 she has the most attitude....The same attitude that helped oust Kady