I actually emailed DVC Member Services when it happened - it was right at end of March, as we went in March, and it was still there during that trip as that was the last time we were able to get some.
They said it was Beach Club's decision, as they needed more room for other food items, as per guest requests. The supervisor I spoke with said that Beach Club is still making 1 fresh/homemade flavour each day, and it will be pre-packed alongside the other third party Gelato product in the case. He also said that Hurricane Hannah's will be selling prepacked as well.
We just returned and didn't go to Beach Club to check it out, as we are very upset with this decision, as this was one of our best family activities. We didn't feel like eating packed gelato, so we didn't even go 1x during our 2 week trip. We normally ate the gelato multiple times on each trip, so we were really missing it. Our DD7 was very upset that they have done this.
So, since I haven't tasted it, I can't comment on quality or taste, but I will say that we really missed going to BCV and getting the gelato this trip, and strolling along the Boardwalk, hand in hand, while walking under the stars, after a long day of parks.
Tiger