next year's choices...

[daisyx3]

We would like to take a longer Fantasy cruise in summer 2020 (limited by teaching schedule). We are not going to WDW next year (saving DCL points for 2021). This would be DCL #6 since 03; previously 3 4 nighters, one 3 night, one 7 night, all 4 ships.
The last few years we have only taken 4-5 night trips as DH runs a small business and it is hard for him to get away. Even if we rent a lake house near home he usually drives to the office a couple of times. But if this is our one big trip in 2020 he is more open to it.
So here are the choices I have:
1) 5 night to Cozumel and CC on 7/6. I don't want to do Nassau again; we stayed onboard last year and plan to do so this June as well. So this is shorter but a different itinerary.
2) 6/13 7 night to Tortola and St. Thomas and CC. I have never been to either, and they both sound like good spots with nice snorkel/beach things to do.
3) 7 night to Cozumel, Cayman and Falmouth, and CC. I have been to Cozumel and Cayman but it was in 04. Would probably do the falls in Falmouth. This is cheaper than the eastern if we leave 6/6; more if we leave 6/20.
Obviously the 5 night is the least expensive (pricing out 5E aft for all).
Anyone have input? All opinions appreciated.

 

[i18mulan]

The 7 night to Tortola, St. Thomas and CC would be a whole new experience to you since you’ve been to Cozumel and Cayman before. As I’ve never been to Western Caribbean, I couldn’t speak for it. But the Eastern ports (Tortola and St. Thomas) have beautiful beaches! The Baths in Tortola is really beautiful IMO, and so is Trunk Bay in St. John.