Narcoossee's or Fulton's

[lilmape]

My husband and I are taking a trip to Disney in February. It will be our last before we start our family. I want to surprise him with a special romantic seafood dinner . We will be paying out of pocket because I have reserved all of our Dining Plan sit down meals already and I don't want to use 4 (2 each) at one place. I have reviewed menus on allears.com and narrowed my choices to Narcoossee's and Fulton's... Which would you pick and why? I've heard you can see fireworks from the dining room at Narcoosee's is that true?

Some background - We went to disney on our honeymoon in 2007. We ate at Fulton's and really enjoyed it.

 

[Kit'smommy]

I have given Narcoossee's two chances, but DH and I just don't love it. However, it is a good spot for viewing the fire works.

Fulton's is my favorite restaurant on property. We go there 4-5 times a year and always enjoy it.

Citrico's is another restaurant I would recommend. You can't see the fireworks and it isn't entirely seafood (though they usually have several wonderful seafood dishes), but the atmosphere is very nice and the food is terrific.

 

[Madhatter266]

We have been to both restaurants two times. At Narcoosee's our meals were excellent and the service was wonderful. At Fulton's, both times, our dinners were mediocre, and the service was really bad. The reason we went back after the first experience was because we thought it may have been an off-night. But both times it was the same. At one point, we thought that our server had left the building because we couldn't find him anywhere. We couldn't get drink refills and had a difficult time getting our check.

Everyone has their own opinion based upon their own experiences, but as you could probably guess, I would go to Narcoosee's.

 

[Nanajo1]

We had a so-so dinner at Nicoosees. We will try it again incase we got it on an off night. There are many people who rave about it. We like Fulton's but don't get stuck on the third floor. No matter how good the wait staff is the service is slow. We really enjoyed the Artist Point at WL.

 

[OKW Lover]

We've been to both and would give Narcoossee's the nod. Fulton's was OK, but not great. Narcoossee's was a better dining experience from both a food and service perspective.

 

[DizDaD7]

For me, I mean us, Fulton's hands down. Not even close IMHO. Good luck

 

[jen42002]

We went to Narcoosees for dinner and Fulton's for lunch last month. We had great food and service at Narcoosees. Our lunch at Fulton's was not good at all. I have heard ok things about dinner there but have a hard time believing it with how our lunch was. I also prefer the atmosphere and decor at Narcoosees.

 

[Redbudlover]

We have been to both restaurants two times. At Narcoosee's our meals were excellent and the service was wonderful. At Fulton's, both times, our dinners were mediocre, and the service was really bad. The reason we went back after the first experience was because we thought it may have been an off-night. But both times it was the same. At one point, we thought that our server had left the building because we couldn't find him anywhere. We couldn't get drink refills and had a difficult time getting our check.

Everyone has their own opinion based upon their own experiences, but as you could probably guess, I would go to Narcoosee's.

My experience at fultons was the same - once I sent the food back because it was cold and it came back cold and over-cooked. And the service was bad. Both times... Menus don't tell the whole story. Two dishes can have the same description and one be a whole lot better than the other. I love Narcoossees and go there often but it does not compare to Flying Fish - imho.... Though Narcoossee has the advantage of seeing Wishes during your meal...

 

[SharonZ]

Definitely Narcoose's.

 

[Dis_Yoda]

Fulton's handsdown. I've been there 3 times in the past year and loved it each time!

 

[Pocahantas]

Definately Narcoossees

 

[connie1042]

Well after reading the post, I am sure you made a decision. LOL. It looks like 50/50. We have been to both and do both on every trip. I just thought I would add to the 50/50. Really, we enjoy both just the same. Fulton's does not take the dinning plan unless you are on premium plan, I think, but you are not using the dinning plan for that meal anyway. At Fulton's we love to sit on the back deck of the boat and people watch and just enjoy the views. Narcossee's we love to watch the fireworks.. Don't worry about getting a table by a window, at Narcossee's, you all walk out to the deck to watch the fireworks.

 

[Disney_Dawg]

Another vote for Narcoossee's

 

[lilmape]

Well after reading the post, I am sure you made a decision. LOL. It looks like 50/50. We have been to both and do both on every trip. I just thought I would add to the 50/50. Really, we enjoy both just the same. Fulton's does not take the dinning plan unless you are on premium plan, I think, but you are not using the dinning plan for that meal anyway. At Fulton's we love to sit on the back deck of the boat and people watch and just enjoy the views. Narcossee's we love to watch the fireworks.. Don't worry about getting a table by a window, at Narcossee's, you all walk out to the deck to watch the fireworks.

LOL isn't it obvious? I really can't decide. We LOVED Fulton's. We had fantastic service last time and the food was delicious. The only seafood we typically get in Southern Ohio is Red Lobster.. So you can imagine that we're not terribly picky (Nothing against Red Lobster). I just want a romantic yummy seafood meal. I loved strolling around DTD after dinner last time... But fireworks are so romantic. I'll give it a little longer and see what everyone says. Thank you ALL for responding and sharing your opinions!

 

[MickeyNicki]

We have been to Fultons 5 times and each time the food and service is fantastic...same thing with our 3 times at Flying Fish, just excellent!

We are trying Narcoosee's for the first time next month and cannot wait, have read some great reviews recently

 

[Letsbgoofy]

We ate at Narcossees for our anniversary last August. We were on the DP but I did take a look at our bill. The food was good but not great, portions were rather small. 2 entrees, 2 desserts, no alcohol for $130; not worth the price for food and service that wasn't outstanding in my opinion.

 

[HsvTeacher]

Another vote for Narcoossee's!

We ate there in July and the food and service were both outstanding! Can't wait until we can do it again!