I just stumbled across your TR this morning and must say I loved reading all of it. My husband and I just returned from a trip for our 1st anniversary and I loved reliving some of your anniversary memories too.
Your husband did an amazing job planning everything, he kind of sounds like my hubby who does the Disney thing because he knows how much I love it. I would be so impressed if he ever figured out how to make a dining reservation let alone plan an entire trip. From the roses and the gift basket to all the dining plans, you really had a great trip.
I'm glad you were able to try Yachtsman and Ohanas' (the second is a must on every trip for us!) Sorry you were disappointed at CRT. I've never been at breakfast, but I must say the dinner we did there the night after our wedding was really delicious although for the cost I would take Yachtsman any day!