I was a little leery about dining here due to recent Dis reviews and shared experiences. I don't know if others hit an unlucky day, or I hit a lucky one, but I finally found my one MUST HAVE WDW dish. What I ate was get-away-from-my-plate-or-I-will-stab-your-hand-good. I had made an ADR probably 2 or more weeks ago. When we arrived the place was busy, but there was available seating. I don't know if they were aceepting walk ups or not. But there were empty tables. Three adults. We each had ice teas to drink. They were flavored -- blackberry or current. Something like that. Our server "warned" us before hand they were flavored. That was fine with us. One in our group had the Sheperds Pie. Another (I think) ordered Paddy's Pork. I ordered Pie in the Sky - chicken and wild mushroom pie served with a rocket lettuce salad. Yes, I was hungry. But this was just PERFECT, OMG good. There was nothing that could have been improved. The chicken was tender and great tasting. As was the crust. Creamy. Smooth. Perfect temperature too. The greens salad (not iceberg lettuce) was more than enough, and had a light dressing that was very good too. The person eating the Sheperds Pie said their dish was very good. The third person liked their dish, but said the food could have been warmer. From what they described their food was room temperature, and the plate it came on was hotter than the food. We were all too full to eat dessert. We did not have any appetizers, nor were we served any bread. Just as well (for me) because I could not have finished my entree. And being that my entree included a delicious pie crust, I did not need bread anyway. We were in and out in roughly an hour. Very good service. Always had drink refills without asking. All staff were friendly from the time we checked in until we left. We never heard nor saw any entertainment at RR. Maybe Saturdays are a better day to go. BUt this is the one place that TOMORROW I am calling in an ADR for a few weeks from now. Pie in the Sky -- here I come!