I think this is a great thread!
When you look at the two resorts from an "attraction" point of view, DL actually has more attractions per amount of space than WDW....WDW is more spread out. And, while the sheer size of WDW means more attractions, hotels, restaraunts, etc., DL does a pretty good job of keeping up. There is certainly some things that DL does better, and some things that WDW has that DL doesn't, and I enjoy both aspects of both parks.
I think the size and transportation are the key differences to me. The busses at WDW have been getting worse and worse over the past 5 years. It is soooo much easier to just walk at DL. We are fortunate; we stay on site every trip at DL. So, it's just a simple walk out the door to DCA or a small walk to DL. But, I agree with what's been posted: if you are able to stay on site at DL, you won't lose that "magic", and it becomes very similar in escapism to WDW.
W