We preferred CBR over POR! After all the great things we heard about POR on the DIS, I was prepared to like it, but it ended up being our least favorite mod. WE had trouble with the bus stop. The main one was very crowded, and it has no queue, so it was a mob scene trying to get on the bus. My MIL had a sore hip when we went, so it was very diificult getting her on the bus witha seat - even when we were one of the first ones at the bus stop. If there hadn't been a large group of us, there's no way she'd have gotten a seat. At the busy times, if you were at one of the secondary stops, there's no way you'd have gotten on our bus at all! I hope another bus came along shortly for those at the secondary stops!
The food court at POR was also our least favorite. CBR was one of our favorites, thouygh it was a few years ago - 2002 - when we stayed there. I understand POR has just improved their food court, but still the one at CBR was bright and cheery, while the POR one was kind of dark. WE got out food very quickly at CBR.
The pool at POR was also our least favorite. The theming was lame. CBR reminds me of PotC, so we liked it much better. The hot tub could be larger, and have more jets, but the one at POR was so strongly chlorinated that I couldn't stay in it for long. Maybe it was just our experience. The chlorine was so strong, my eyes were stinging as soon as I got in. I've never had that at any other WDW hot tub. It was also very crowded. POFQ has a cute pool, but the water slide looked very tame.
I suppose the boatride to DTD at POR is worth something, but when we were there, it was pretty cold on the water. We were chilled just going betwen POR and POFQ.
Both are big resorts. At POR, the magnolia rooms are much nicer, IMO than the Bayou rooms. The fountains are nice, as are the elevators.