I actually grew up right at the Clarke Co/Jackson Co line. Not sure if that's where you are or not. After I got married, I moved to Barrow Co, which is where my husband is from, so now we're about 30 minutes from Athens. However, we're in Athens a good bit since my sister still lives where were grew up and my Dad lives in Athens also.
Pop was just okay to be honest. I guess I've gotten spoiled since joining DVC and having stayed in nothing but the DVC resorts on our past few trips. I always wanted to stay at Pop though, just because it looked so fun, and since we were able to get such a great rate for the night before the cruise, we decided to go with it. It's okay for a night or two, but I don't know if I would want to spend a whole week there. Actually, PO Riverside is another resort that I really want to try. We stayed in CBR back in 2007 for a whole week and really loved it! Of course, all our trips have been in September, so it's a lot slower then, but it was peaceful and quiet. We loved it there! I'm sure that whatever you decided will be fun!