Maya Grill - who would have thought?

ctaci

Mouseketeer
Joined
Jan 20, 2009
Messages
194
Our reservations were for:

Coral Reef
Ohanna
Chef De France
Boma
Kona
Yachtsman Steakhouse
SciFi Drive-In


mayagrill.jpg


On Tuesday I believe it was we were in no mood to go to Yachtsman at 530pm or whatever the reservation was. We canceled the ADR and figured it would free up a TS so then we wouldnt have to pay OOP for SciFi later in the week. We took a nap and headed down to Maya Grill for dinner hoping they would have something open. Of course they did - no wait even. This place is GORGEOUS. The seating is so unlike Disney - everywhere else we went we were sitting on top of other people but not here. The lighting and atmosphere were just really great. The server turned out to be from Barnesville, Ohio - this little dink of a town where I actually went to school for 2yrs while in highschool. I was absolutely shocked that her tag said Barnesville.

So anyhow...

I ordered the filet mignon with onion mashed potatoes and mixed veg (grilled squashes, peppers, onions, carrots) and DH ordered the special which was Paella. He also ordered a side of plantains and we also had drinks - a blackstone merlot and a dirty martini. We also had a soda and soda water. The dinners were really to die for. The steak was out of this world. I would say its the best steak Ive *ever* had and we eat a lot of steaks! The mashed potatoes were so good and I dont even care for onions. I was thrilled they had my wine (the blackstone merlot) so I was of course pleased with that. DH enjoyed his paella but did not like the martini. I dont know why.. he just said it was off. I tried the plantains and they were cut on the bias and not cooked as I normally know them to be cooked but they were the best plantains Ive tasted - they had a wonderful carmelization and I could have ate them all if hed let me.

Then it was dessert time. We are on the DDP so dessert is a must. I had their fried cheesecake and he ordered the creme brulee. I didnt bother having his since I had my fair share of creme brulee. My cheesecake was SO GOOD. It had this coconut sauce or something on the bottom of it.. almost like melted ice cream but maybe just coconut milk or cream? It was really really good. I ate the entire thing no problem. DH liked the creme brulee.. he said it was less sweet than the stuff at the Coral Reef.

We liked this place so much we cancled our Kona reservations for Friday and came back for dinner again. I had the steak tips with mushrooms and he had the duck this time. We both had the fried cheese cake and I started off with a side order of plantains. I ordered the mashed potatoes again and my dinner actually came with a corn husk filled with cornmeal in the shape of a banana that was the same consistancy of a tamale - it was an awesome surprise since I love tamales. DH really liked the duck, it didnt come with anything though but it filled the plate so it must have been enough. We got our cheesecakes to go and they were just as good a few hours later back at our room. They were well packed and even came with plasticware which I was happy about.

Both times our servers were great. The restaurant is geared more towards adults which was perfect for us since we were kidless this vacation. It was by far my favorite place to eat at Disney or anywhere else for that matter.

I took a picture of the dinner menu posted outside the restaurant. The prices arent on it but the filet was $36 I believe. I think all of the dinners were about $30-$36 dollars. Maybe the duck was more.

Loved it. Im really surprised I didnt read anything about it here on the Dis before I left. I know its at Coronado Springs and probably not a popular resort or theres no signature to it but if you are looking for a great dinner with great atmosphere this is the place. There were kids there too so dont be shy to bring them, but its just a bit on the fancy side I guess so maybe they wouldnt like it.. I plan on taking my two here when we go back, or maybe getting a sitter for the little one.

mayagrillmenu.jpg
 
Thanks for the review - you don't hear a lot about Maya Grill but, I have to say, nearly every time it is reviewed, the outcome is positive :thumbsup2
 
Thanks, Ctaci, for the great review. Would you believe in our seven stays at the CSR we have never had dinner at the Maya Grill (we did breakfast twice). I think, after your review, that we are going to have to find a spot for it on our visit in September.
 
Thanks for the review! We are coming in July, and will probably be at CSR by 7:00. I had wondered if the Maya Grill would be a nice "first night" place since we plan to just explore our resort that first night. Now I can plan on eating there with confidence.
 

Maya Grill has been a well kept secret. We eat there once or twice a trip. Usually it's not hard to get an ADR on the same day. Sometimes there is no wait, other times, esp. if there are a lot of conventioneers at CSR there has been a 30 minute or so wait without an ADR.
 
That makes me happy. We are considering this for our last ADR this summer. Thanks!
 
Wow...that's good o hear about Maya Grill :yay:

We stayed at the Coronado a couple of weeks ago and while on one of our bus trips (from Downtown Disney back to the hotel) we were talking with another couple about restaurants and they were NOT at all happy with Maya Grill...so needless to say, we never bothered eating there! Maybe they went on an "off" night.
 
I'm so trilled to hear that you enjoyed your meal. CSR is our resort "home" for our trip this May and we have an ADR for the Maya Grill and just reading your review made my mouth water and has me looking forward to our dinner even more. Thanks.

T.
 





New Posts










Save Up to 30% on Rooms at Walt Disney World!

Save up to 30% on rooms at select Disney Resorts Collection hotels when you stay 5 consecutive nights or longer in late summer and early fall. Plus, enjoy other savings for shorter stays.This offer is valid for stays most nights from August 1 to October 11, 2025.
CLICK HERE













DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top