We had an absolutely wonderful time! The ship was much bigger than the Mag8c. Our room was HUGE! I guess because there were 3 of us in one room, we had a suite, and since we needed handicapped accessible, it was about double the size of a regular suite. It had a huge king bed and a couch that became a single bed. Chuck usually sleeps in the extra bed when we travel, but he thought the bed was too hard, I thought it was just right!
The ship had 3 pools, and lots more entertainment, but part of that is because it was a bigger ship. Pat loved the jazz band and the couple who played in one of the nightclubs. They had a great rock band and a piano bar. There was a guy playing guitar and singing near the bar by the casino. Also a late night nightclub with a DJ and more modern rock music, but we never stayed up late enough to go there!
I liked the casino....I won $500 at the slot tournament! I kind of liked having the casino to go to. I miss that on the Disney ship.
The stage shows were wonderful! Great talent. We didn't go to the magician, but the others were great.
We enjoyed the food, but we like the Disney food better. Our food often came "warm" not hot. The cold fruit soups are a favortie of ours on
DCL, but the ones on Carnival were bland and thin.......no comparison! Our servers were ok, especially our assistant server. As you know, we were a group of 35, and our very good friends were sitting at the table next to us ( wer were a group of 8 at each table). We thought the server was snotty and not friendly, whereas our friends at the other table had the same servers and they thought she was the best one they ever had! That just goes to show that each person sees the service different.
One thing that amazed me was that when we were going by the Stromboli volcano ( a special detour to see it because it was "acting up"), we planned a wine party in our room so everyone could see it together. I phoned room service and asked for 12 red wine glasses, 12 white wine glasses, 12 on the rocks glasses and 12 champagne glasses as well as crackers and cheese. They brought 2 plates of cheese, a big basket of crackers, 2 big buckets of ice, and ALL the glasses I asked for. No problem at all! NO THAT WAS IMPRESSIVE!
I have talked to some of my friends who went on the Magic Med cruise, and we went to many of the same ports of call. They sounded about the same. WE actually saw several Disney tour groups in Monaco/Monte Carlo! That waas fun!
I would go on either one again.
But I will say because of Patrick we would go on Disney, not Carnival. He has more fun with the characters, and the shows are more to his liking, and there was plenty of entertainment for him on the Disney ship. Our main enjoyment is when he is enjoying himself. If it was just Chuck and I, as adults, I would like to try other cruise lines to compare.
Actually, as long as I am travelling, I am happy!