Qball, I must've just missed you. My wife and daughter went to the shopping briefing, and I wandered by, but didn't see anyone.
But the weather was picture-perfect, and we had a blast snorkeling in Nassau - the water wasn't too cold.
And regarding your server - what a coincidence, huh? I noticed that our assistant server worked Beach Blanket Buffet at least once, and I saw both of mine on Castaway Cay. I will say that from those two, I've never had better service on land or on sea. We cruised the Magic in 2000, and I felt like the food was significantly better this time around, and it wasn't bad back then.
Three days was short, though. I missed that sea day, and we're already plotting an Eastern Caribbean cruise for next year.
I may do a trip report. Even though we were in a Cat 11, I didn't feel cramped (we have a travel trailer, so we're used to making the best of smaller spaces!), but I want at least a porthole for a longer cruise. The verandah spoiled me first time around.