Mama Melrose F! or Brown Derby

Discussion in 'Disney Dining Plan' started by IncredibleboysMom, Dec 3, 2010.

  1. IncredibleboysMom

    IncredibleboysMom DIS Veteran

    Sep 7, 2006
    We just returned from a wonderful Thanksgiving trip with the kids. DH and I are returning marathon weekend (he's the runner) alone. We splurged on DxDP with the agreement that we would eat places we wouldn't typically go with kids. His favorite thing on Disney property is Fantasmic, and the only show is the night after he runs the marathon. I booked a F! package at MM for lunch because we are having a late dinner at Citricos. We've been to MM before and liked it, but we have a dining credit unaccounted for, and I was wondering if we shouldn't try the Brown Derby. We would never go there with our boys. I guess the bottom line is whether or not we will really need that preferred seating for Fantasmic in Jan. What'cha think?

  2. ragtopday

    ragtopday Proud Member of Red Sox Nation

    Aug 25, 2007
    I don't know whether you will need preferred seating for Fantasmic in January, but I say if you have the chance (and credits) to do HBD, do it! MM is someplace you might take your kids to, but HBD is much more adult - I think you'll enjoy that much more, F! package or not.
  3. Avatar


    to hide this advert.
  4. Pakey

    Pakey DIS Veteran

    Aug 29, 2007
    Fantasmic is crowded, even in January.

    We have done the Brown Derby Fantasmic package several times and we've always been very happy with the meal. Since we eat at Brown Derby anyway, it's a no brainer to do the package.
  5. PoohsFan1

    PoohsFan1 DIS Veteran

    Feb 19, 2007
    I agree with the others and go to HBD because it is a 2 credit/signature status restaurant. We personally have never eaten there before because my kids are very picky eaters, but if it was just DH and I, we would eat there in an instant. We have a MM F package for lunch booked for May, which we do really like MM, but MM has more of a family atmosphere with Italian dishes that most kids like anyways. So for your situation go with HBD :goodvibes
  6. paxsarah

    paxsarah DIS Veteran

    Dec 20, 2007
    We're doing the F! package at Mama Melrose the same day with little kids + grandparents, but in your situation I would totally switch to the Brown Derby.
  7. jmhazlett

    jmhazlett Mouseketeer

    Apr 1, 2004
    Brown Derby hands down. We did MM last week and were not impressed. Brown Derby has always met expectations.

Share This Page