We've stayed in that cabin on the Magic right after the Re-Imagining (11/20/13). Verandah isn't very big to us but that is only because we had only been on the Dream in 5192 prior to this one. Others say 5150 is a larger verandah - I'm assuming they are comparing to regular verandahs on the Magic. It does have standing water often from the cleanings/spray washers above. We chose 5162 on the Wonder next and it was a better size verandah for sure.