We loved LTT and are going there again this trip - on our first night! We thought the food was fine! I've also read a lot of negative comments about the food tasting *processed* but I'm not sure what that means. Sometimes I make Kraft Mac and Cheese for my crew and the LTT version didn't taste anything like that! The meat was good, we liked the stuffing and gravy, the string beans seemed to be fresh, not frozen and the dessert was delicious!
Maybe I am not a good judge of this type of "American" food as I am Puerto Rican. While I can cook a lot of different foods, from Lasagna to Goulash, I have never mastered the traditional Thanksgiving type meal! So, YMMV!
BUT - while we liked the food, we reeeaallyy liked the atmosphere! The restaurant was lovely, the service was good and we had plenty of time with the characters.
The CP....well. The food was great, better than the LTT (the salmon was especially good!). But it was SO crowded and we didn't get much attention from the characters. It was SO crowded and it was hard to get to the buffet tables. It was SO crowded and it took a long time to get more drinks. Honestly, my children loved it but it gave me a headache. So, this time around we are trying an early breakfast. I will miss the salmon but I'm hoping for a more peaceful meal!
I hope this helps you make a decision!