Little Help please??

[jekajekalynn]

Hi,
I am gonna surprise my dm with a birthday meal while we are all at WDW for our Magical gathering. She thinks we are just all going out to eat , but I am trying to make it a surprise birthday meal, and I have a few question.

I have my restraunts narrowed down to; LeCellier, Mama Melrose, Flame Tree BBQ, and Liberty Tree . Which is the best resteraunt to have this at?

Also, do any of these places do anything special if you mention when you make a PS that it is someones birthday( I really can't tell the CM at the podium because it would spoil the surprise lol)?

Thanks!!

 

[PrincessTrisha]

Flametree is a counter service restaurant so I don't think they would do anything special.

My first choice would be Le Cellier (but they are also the most expensive of the list) Liberty Tree Tavern could be nice because it is character dining at dinner and they would probably make a fuss over her. I've never been to Mama Melrose so I really can't say there.

 

[CamColt]

Out of your choices, I would want my celebration at Mama Melrose. Its one of our favorite restaurants. While Le Cellier might be a little "nicer" than MM, I do prefer the food at MM, so that would be my deciding factor.

 

[Grumpy92]

I would vote for Le Cellier or Mama Melrose. The dining room at MM is larger but the food at both locations is wonderful.

 

[cseca]

I vote for Le Cellier because I've had great experience with them.
Never been to MM, but the reviews are mixed.
LTT is character dinner. They are fun... so depends on what kind of dinner you want this b'day to be.
FTBBQ as PrincessTrisha pointed out is a counterservice, so it won't be as special...

Have fun!

 

[estnh]

Le Cellier gets another vote here. It is a great place for a birthday celebration, and they WILL make a fuss--it is my teen age daughter's favorite restaurant, and she has celebrated several birthdays there!

 

[Densgirl]

My Dh had his 35th birthday dinner at Le Cellier and they made a big deal out of him. I mentioned it when I made the PS and didn't mention it at the poduim because like your DM he was with me and I didn't want to make a big deal with him standing right there. They even brought him a complimentary dessert. Great food and atmosphere here but it isn't exactly cheap. Good luck choosing.