We were at WDW this past May and ate at both places. Let me dig out the receipts ...
Sci Fi: We (dh, myself, and two boys, ages 13 and 5) ate there for lunch and loved it!
Appies: Dh had the onion rings, ds1 had the chili (I have no idea why he wanted chili
), and I had the spinach artichoke dip. We all shared our appies with each other and with ds2, since he was on the kids' plan. I liked my dip and chips so much that I got the recipe and have made it at home three times now.
Main Dishes: Burger, rib plate, and chicken bruschetta with fries. No complaints from anyone.
Desserts: Chocolate tart, cheesecake, and water (ds1 was too full, so the lady brought out a bottle of water for him). OMG the cheesecake was too much! It had caramel popcorn, m&ms, whipped topping, AND caramel sauce with it! It was good, but I wasn't expecting something like that (and I didn't finish it).
Ds 2 had the pizza kids' meal. He ate some of it, but he was full from what we gave him from our meals.
Oh, yeah, and both got chocolate shakes as their drinks.
Coral Reef: We ate there for dinner and were happy with it.
Appies: Land and Sea, shrimp cocktail, and cod cake. I really liked the land and sea, but the portions were really tiny. The shrimp cocktail was good, albeit flimsy. The cod cake was good, too.
Main dishes: Dh had the king crab legs. They were HUGE, and he said they were really good. I read here that they've been discontinued.
. I had a NY strip. It was all right, but I had a fillet at Le Cellier the day before and think that ruined any future steak experiences for me
. Ds1 had the grilled chicken. He said it was the best chicken he's ever had.
Desserts: Ds1 and I had the chocolate wave (dh took ds' cherries for him), and dh had the mousse and loved it.
Ds2 had the salmon kids' meal with fruit salad and sundae and ate it ALL.
Conclusion: I personally enjoyed both restaurants. Dh says the CR was his all time favorite restaurant. I say Le Cellier was, lol. While the Sci Fi was excellent with the theming and food, I probably won't be a repeat visitor for a while. This trip was our very first, and we want to try out other places during our next visit.
Sorry this was so long, but you did ask ...