IN all fairness it has been several years since our last meal at CG. WE did like CG but we love JIKO and honestly I think they're 2 very different types of places. Atmosphere is quite different as well.
WE LOVE JIKO and in all the times we've been there, we have always had a great experience. I've had several things from their menu and they've all been outstanding (some items are no longer on the menu that I've had
but that's the way it goes sometimes). The service has always been good, never had a problem there either. Price-wise it's pretty much the same as CG, FF and DEFINITELY CHEAPER than YSH, so I don't quite get that one???
We went to YSH in Dec. for the first time in a long time and I wasn't all that impressed as this was one of our favs once. Anyway that's besides the point.
JIKO has some authentic ways of preparing their dishes. This was the first place I had monkfish which was just excellent but unfortunately it is no longer on the menu. The cucumber, tomatoe and onion salad is a favorite that I always get and I'm not a big onion fan but the dressing is light with a watermelon taste which is so unique but very pleasing to the palet. And, this past trip (just last week), I tried the filet and it was OUTSTANDING!! Probably one of the best filets I've ever had!! I may get "stuck" on that there now
I have to tell you, I went to cut into it and I prefer my meat medium, it was so soft I thought it would be "moooing" but it was done perfect, don't know how they can get the meat so tender after cooking it almost all the way through, just delicious. My dd also likes their grilled cheese. We like sitting by the window where the pond area is. Sometimes there are ducks swimming around which is kinda fun to watch.
Anyway, of course you'll have those who like and those who don't (but many more who DO LIKE)...we heard lots of great reviews before we first tried it and our expectations were met and it's always been consistently good after going back several times in the past few years (wish I could say that of other WDW restaurants). TRY IT!!