My 4 yo dd LOVED the clubs. We had to pry her out of there!!! It was much harder for ds7, though. The staff was friendly and accomodating, but it was pretty overwhelming for Sam. On our first
Castaway Cay day, we had Flounders ressies for our two younger girls in the afternoon, and dh and I planned to hang out in hammocks on Serenity Bay for a little bit. DH took the girls back and I checked the older kids in at Scuttles Cove. Then, I went to observe from a distance. It broke my heart to see my son struggle so much. It wasn't that anyone was actively being mean to him, but all the kids were pretty much ignoring him, and everytime he went near a group of boys they'd kind of look at him and walk away. Once I saw him try to do some water bucket dump that was part of a game, and I saw kids laughing. He looked truly miserable. At that point, even though he is 7, I wished he was in the 3/4 group so that he'd be with his sister--- they love being together. I actually checked into that ,and they were willing to make the switch, but it would have to be permenant an dnot just for that day. Anyway, after watching for a few minutes I actually went back to Scuttles and thought I'd check in on him. Sure enough, when I got to him the counselor said she was just about to page me because he had asked for me. After that day, he really didn't want to go to the clubs at all--- unless there was a movie or something like that where the social interactions were less high pressure.
The staff was great with him, and the few times he went to the club and around the ship it was clear that every single counselor in the 5-7 group knew him. He loved doing the "Remember the Magic" show with everyone else (if anyone was on the cruise and saw the show, he was the one in the middle taking big bows during the applause, LOL!!)
Fortunately, the clubs to us were just another option for the kids to have fun so it wasn't a big deal that it didn't really impress him too much. On the other hand, DD as I mentioned loved them a lot. I just figured, we were on vacation-- and so was he-- -and we weren't going to check him in if he was going to struggle and feel frustrated there. That didn't sound like much fun at all!!! He did love the late evenings when they showed movies. And, he loved the activity of learning to be a pirate!!! All totalled over the 7 days, he probalby spent about 7 hours total in the clubs.
Jelly.