Il Mulino or Tutto Italia?

[jackskellingtonsgirl]

I am starting to kick around our choices for next summer. We have TONS of places for seafood and I thought Italian would be a nice change of pace. I think NOT Tony's or Mama Melrose.

So that leaves Tutto Italia or Il Mulino. We are NOT on DDP, but we do have a DDE card. I don't think either place takes DDE so all things are equal! We are staying at Beach Club for the second half of the trip so they are both pretty convenient.

So which is better?

 

[Robert P]

We've only been to Il Mulino so far, but are definitely going back next trip. Being outside a park, it was not crowded, and the service was top notch. Amazing food.

If the search function is working, you can find my review from our Oct/Nov trip.

 

[Desnik]

We have only been to Tutto Italia. It was fantastic! I day dream about our meal there!LOL The food was so fresh and tasty and the service was top notch! I can't wait to go back. My DH and our kids(9 & 4) all loved it so much too. We were on the DDP so it was a lot of food for us, but we ate it all anyway!

 

[jackskellingtonsgirl]

I am thinking that Tutto Italia may very well be closed in August. I have read that they are closing in "Spring 2008" and reopening "Late 2008" so that doesn't look promising. I guess we'll see what's actually open and go from there!

 

[Uncleromulus]

Based on the menus, Il Mulino appears to be a clear winner. We're trying it this May!!

 

[byoung]

Tutto Italia gets our vote.