Last year, there were NOOO character meal ADRs available 3 months prior to our trip - I'm the type that has ADRs, but always tweaking and moving things around, and that was impossible to do.
That was not my experience. I went Christmas 09 and September 10 with FD and with the exception of the Canadian Steakhouse in EPCOT, I was able to get all restuarants (including character meals) i wanted. Sometimes I had to modify times a little but it was a good experience overall.