My 3 year old is the type of kid who has never liked Santa or Easter Bunny. He won't go near them.
So, I had no idea how our character meals were going to go. However, since I have two other kids (DD5.5, DS 13months), I didn't want to deprive them of the experience.
He loved them.
We did Akershus dinner first. Unintentionally, I think that worked out well because it's face characters which were probably much less intimidating (and since my DD was really into it, he could hang back and watch without having to get too involved). Two days later we did CP lunch, which was awesome since he loves all the Pooh characters. Then three days later we did CM breakfast, and again, he loved it.
So, even if your kids are shy, you might be surprised. I have a child I know does not love characters that are supposed to be kids' favorites and yet, he did very well at Disney character meals.
ETA: I didn't read all the responses here so I now see that my kid isn't alone in his fear of Santa, EB but love of Disney. It must be that 'ol Disney magic again.
