Thanks for writing such a detailed review. Sorry you didn't enjoy it. Such a shame because it was beautiful when we were there years ago. We actually ended up deciding to book Wyndham Bonnet Creek instead. Thanks again.
Since I posted my review last month, we stayed at WBC.
Room-wise, WBC and OL are about the same. Both are nice and spacious. And both are clean enough.
Parking: Giving the edge to OL. At OL, you can park right at your door. Not so at WBC. It's hard to find parking at WBC, especially at the end of the day. Sometimes, you have to go into one of the parking garages.
Grocery shopping and nearby restaurants: Again, giving the edge to OL. There are restuarants and a Publix just as you enter the resort. At WBC, we actually went on I-4 to get to a Publix. Although the expressway is close enough to WBC.
Where WBC excels at is: everything else. Everything is right there. You can walk to everything, while with OL, you need a car. WBC built up, not out. While (IIRC), everything at OL is on one or two stories, WBC built towers that go up to the 18th floor. Also, WBC doesn't nickel and dime you on everything. You want to cruise one of its lazy rivers? You just grab a tube and start floating.
And that's not to mention its proximity to the parks. (Though I wonder...which resort is closer to AK, OL or WBC. When we stayed at OL four years ago, we sorta got lost going to AK).
You'll have fun. Wish I was going back.