Help me pick 3 out of these 4 signatures

[lobsterkmd]

I am having a tough time deciding on picking THREE out of these Four Signatures

1) Flying Fish
2) Citricos
3) Artist Point
4) Narcossee's

I will be traveling with my mother and DD(9). I eat pretty much everything, my mother doesn't eat much red meat and DD is a super steak lover. ( we already have reservations at Yachtsman one night.)

Thanks for your help

Kristin

 

[Sgt Tibbs]

Tough choice, I like them all;

I would keep Flying Fish and Citrico's. The sirlon at both is great if you are not a fish eater.

If you have never explored the Wilderness Lodge keep Artist Point, your DD might like the buffalo steak if she is a red meat eater. The mushroom soup and salmon are also very good there.

If the Wilderness Lodge and buffalo, etc. are old hat keep Narcoosee's your Mom will enjoy the Lobster.

I enjoy all of these restaurants no matter what you pick you should have a good meal. Enjoy!

 

[ddluvsdisney]

I am having a tough time deciding on picking THREE out of these Four Signatures

1) Flying Fish
2) Citricos
3) Artist Point
4) Narcossee's

I will be traveling with my mother and DD(9). I eat pretty much everything, my mother doesn't eat much red meat and DD is a super steak lover. ( we already have reservations at Yachtsman one night.)

Thanks for your help

Kristin

We have eaten at 3 of the 4. FF, AP and Narcoossees. All were excellent!! Since Narcoossees and Citricos are both at GF I would go with Narcoosees- with a late ADR to see the electrical water pageant and Wishes. The surf and turf is to die for!!! FF is my DH's new favorite. The BW is really fun at night after dinner with all the performers.

 

[Sweet Melissa]

I think Narcoossee's is the weakest of the signature restaurants. It's more casual than the rest and the food isn't remarkable. You'll get much better seafood at Flying Fish, better atmosphere at Artist Point, and a better Grand Floridian restaurant at Citricos.

 

[Pakey]

Narcoosees is my least favorite of all the signatures. Unless you have small children you are wanting to entertain (which you don't), I'd skip this one. It does have wonderful views of the lagoon and boats but the food and atmosphere are not at the same level as the other signatures.

The other 3 I would rank as 1. Flying Fish 2. Citricos and 3. Artist Point

 

[mlg32]

Definitely Flying Fish, our food is always excellent. I had some homemade gnocchi and a lobster salad at one meal that are 2 of the best things I have ever eaten))

It has been awhile since we have eaten at Citricos but I know we all enjoyed our meal. Narcossees was good but nothing WOW, JMO.

Enjoy!

 

[madalex]

I think Narcoossee's is the weakest of the signature restaurants. It's more casual than the rest and the food isn't remarkable. You'll get much better seafood at Flying Fish, better atmosphere at Artist Point, and a better Grand Floridian restaurant at Citricos.

+1 to this.

Narcoosees is my least favorite of all the signatures. Unless you have small children you are wanting to entertain (which you don't), I'd skip this one. It does have wonderful views of the lagoon and boats but the food and atmosphere are not at the same level as the other signatures.

+1 to this also.

 

[3pletprincesses]

Narcoosees! been there twice this year and we were disappointed both times.

 

[OhThePain]

Flying Fish and Citricos are our top 2 Signatures (I use that term loosely and don't include V&A's, Shula's or bluezoo when I say "Signature" because they don't accept the dining plans), we can't decide which we like and enjoy more. They are both far above and beyond any of the other Signatures. Artist Point, while not as good as FF and Citricos, ranks pretty high on our list.

Narcoossee's ranks pretty low on our list of Signatures (and there are some 1 TS restaurants that we rank higher than it).

 

[Hootch]

your top three. Flying Fish is just all around good. Citricos is refined anx AP has the best atmosphere.

(At least to me.)

 

[librarygeek]

For what it's worth, we loved Narcoossee's. The food was so good and it was awesome to be able to see Wishes and the electrical water pageant while dining. The lobster I had there was amazing, and DH loved the surf and turf.

 

[MicRac]

I vote for Artist Point. It covers the red meat for your daughter and has delicious seafood for your mom. I second the mushroom soup is delicious. The resort is so pretty and the dinner is so peaceful.

 

[meggiebeth]

I would keep Citricos- we had a wonderful meal there. Service, food and atmosphere are all top notch!

 

[Silver Queen]

We have dined at all of these restaurants and I definitely agree with the posters who felt you should drop Narcoosees. As one poster mentioned there are some non-signature restaurants that are better than Narcoosee. We go to Maine fairly frequently so the lobster at Narcoosees is not impressive to us. FF and Citricos are probably our favorite signatures.

 

[cbg1027]

I'd get rid of Narcoossee's without a second thought. It's not signature worthy - it's casual, loud, the service is just ok, and the food is just ok. Not acceptable when I'm paying signature prices.

Citricos, Flying Fish, and AP are great. You'll have plenty of options to satisfy everyone at those places. Citricos and AP have a good mix of fish and meat entrees. Flying Fish is, obviously, mostly fish, but they have a really good steak that is always on the menu.

 

[MickeyNicki]

I would ditch Narcoossee's