Okay, 2-bedrom gold season (5,000 old points / 8,000 new points value) is probably worth about $1,500 - $2000, not including closing costs, in my opinion. $3K is not terribly over price, but initial cost really isn't the big expense of timesharing, so tell your brother to just enjoy the usage and not worry too much over water under the bridge; just create many precious memories on vacation with his family. I will say that HGVC is my most favorite ownership and timeshare system (ops, did I just say that out loud in a
DVC forum?). However, although timeshare is not an investment, DVC has held it's value better and only timeshare to increase in value, so it's a very close 2nd to me. But I will be honest, Hawaii vacation is best for me, but my family love Disney too, so whatever makes the family happy

.
Great3