DW & I ate there in May, 2003 for our 29th annivesary. DW does not eat any kind of fish so she had steak and loved it. I had something they called a New England Boiled Seafood dinner. It consisted of lobster, crab, calms, mussells, shrimp, and scalops over a bed of about 2 pounds of linguine. I though it was well worth the price.
I have heard both good and bad reports about Fulton's, but then I have seen good and bad reports on nearly every Disney dinning experience and have reached the conclusion that everyone has to try for themselves and reach their own conclusion about that particular restaurant. Over the years I hav eaten at over 20 different restaurants at Disney World and have found only 3 that I did not care for. I will not name those restaurants as I have seen many good reports from other people about these same places.
So, to reiterate, it is completly a matter of personal taste. Remember, One persons poison is another persons pleasure.