One thing a lot of people are forgetting is there is a huge number of people out there who have no idea (and never have known) that it was possible to get discounts on their
Disney vacations...people who just pay rack rate & full ticket & full dining prices and put it down to "Disney is expensive." Won't make any difference to this group that discounts disappear when they didn't know about them in the first place.
These people may have slowed down on their vacations, or skipped them the last couple of years while the economy was bad. But once they feel comfortable enough with the economy, they will go right back to booking their Disney vacation at full price, no debate.
Even with all the advertising Disney does, people still just don't get that discounts apply to them. I remember being in line for a bus during one
Free Dining promo a couple of years ago (when we were booked there with Free Dining ourselves) and overhearing conversations that revolved around "gee I sure wish we belonged to the Disney Vacation Club so we could get that Free dining that other guy was talking about...boy are they lucky!" and the other couple talking about how they all should join the Vac. Club so they could get access to the room discounts. That was a year where there had been Free Dining general public, as well as the stay-4, get 3 free promos, and I don't remember what all. Both of the couples had booked their vacations at full rates. During slow Season, to make it more affordable...not realizing they could have had huge discounts if they'd known to ask when they'd booked in the Spring.