We're not ones for scheduled ADR's but we've been to WDW 39 visits and going in January too. January tends to be an off, slow time so we don't do ADR's. There are so many places to eat with so many different varieties of food cuisines, you can just about eat anywhere most times without ADR's. We don't like to vacation being ruled by our watch but eat when we're hungry wherever we pick. Remember, meals at Disney are alittle pricey but that's because they are huge, even the hamburger and fries is a full meal deal. Wife and I share even that meal. I'ld go to Deb Willis web site and peruse her menus of all the Disney resturants and look at the meals and prices and plan accordingly to what park you'll be in as to where you can eat without jumping all over a park or switching parks just to eat. Her site lists about everything, allears.net I believe.
We like Chef's Mickeys for a character breakfast but there are alot of others who like all the other character meals offered. To us, one character meal is enough, again pricey and buffet, all you can eat. We tend to lean towards the you need fuel to walk around WDW and not want to load up on buffets if we can help it, best buffet for us is at FW, Trails End for breakfast, but we stay at the WL so its just a boat ride. Traveling around the property seeking out your reservations can be tedious, huge spread, so we chow down at a park we're in or our resort. Some special places we like to dine we do on the way out or back to a park, such as Beaches and Cream is at the Y&B Club so we exit EPCOT thru the International Gateway, 5 minutes we're at Beaches and Cream, and then bus back to the MK and boat to the WL.
I know this is confusing for a first timer, just don't get caught up in all the ADR's and character meals, you'll never starve in WDW, too many places to eat from counter service, snack bars, full service. You can easily do a vacation and eat everywhere without an ADR and enjoy it thoroughly. Really suggest going to Deb Willis site and alittle research on meals.