Finding Nemo or Shark Tale?

[brambletiger]

Which did you like most? Who do you love more Nemo or Oscar?

 

[Miffy2003]

Oh, Finding Nemo without a doubt for me. I could watch it and watch it and see new stuff whereas once was enough for me with Shark's Tale. I did enjoy Oscar though!

 

[wils]

Nemo for me.

DD barely watched Shark's Tale and wasn't upset when we took it back to Blockbuster (glad we only rented!)

Nemo - we bought the day it came out and she asked to watch it every day for months (much as I loved it, it nearly drove me crazy). We also have a fair bit of merchandise!

However I do agree with Miffy - Oscar was great

 

[wisbucky]

Finding Nemo is outstanding. I could watch that over and over. Actually have but dont tell DH.

 

[kimwim8]

NEMO without a doubt. Shark Tale was good, but not of NEMO caliber.

 

[CheezDoodle]

Finding Nemo!

 

[browneyes]

I haven't seen Shark Tale, but it would be hard for them to beat Finding Nemo.

 

[MECH8T7]

I liked Finding Nemo better, but other than the fact that they are both animated features about sea life, Finding Nemo is a very different movie from Shark Tales. Both Shark Tales and Shrek are have many more pop culture references than most Disney movies, which is much of the appeal to the over 18 crowd. The only Disney animated movie that seems to have done this in a noticeable way was Alladdin, but I am assuming that some of this was attributable to Robin Williams' ad-libs.

In 10 years time, Finding Nemo will be just as enjoyable to a whole new group of people but I am not sure that this will be as true with Shark Tales or Shrek.

 

[Glucas]

am I alone, I hated sharktails, I want my 70 minutes back

 

[Tinkerbellfan144]

Sharktale for sure!! Nemo was cool gets old quick. I saw it once in theaters, rented it , watched 20 minutes, got tired, started saying the dialouge, turned it off, returned it. Sharktale I saw in theaters, bought it,watched it 5 times, not bored!

 

[EltonJohn]

I've only seen Finding Nemo.

 

[soccercruiser87]

Finding Nemo!

 

[rachael_loves_disney]

I voted for "Loved Both"
Finding Nemo probably has the edge over Sharks Tale..i really did find both very funny though.
The end of Finding Nemo always has me in tears though.. =P Can't help it, it's emotional.

 

[DisneyRocks=D]

Finding Nemo, of course =D I love that lil guy!

 

[ktink]

I voted for Both. both loved Nemo. But DH and I really loved Shark Tales.

 

[*Tru3_pixi3*]

I love both!!!!

 

[DisneyJen0504]

Is this really a question? We know Nemo is the best!

 

[Badger Brent]

I honestly just saw sharktale this afternoon. I really went in with a open mind. I just didn't like it at all. I hope disney reups with pixar.

 

[Tink3rb3ll]

I loved both... I`m probably leaning more toward Finding Nemo, though.

 

[goofyandplutoluver]

i am the outcast i voted shark tale