There's more to just high risk cars.- sporty etc.
I would not go with a Honda Accord- as they are the #1 stolen vehicle in the US...check with your agent as to which cars have a high theft risk.
A few things to make sure of- make sure its 4 door, has ABS, Dual Airbags, Alarm etc...
The cost of replacement is also figured in, or repair. If a car is cheap to repair- body panels etc..its cheaper to insure.
I was never on my parents insurance, always had my own, from my first car. I was 17, brand new 4 door sedan car, and paid $1300 a year with full coverage (due to a loan)
Also- figure out what's the better deal, liability only, or collision. If the collision insurance is more than the cars worth, go with liability, but if the collision doenst raise it much, get it, as if she is in an accident, you can get the car repaired.
My DMIL has a Trans Am, that my DH and his brothers bought her for her 25th wedding anniversary- my youngest DBIL was still in highschool, living at home, and she had one heck of a time getting it insured, just because of that. They said "he could drive it" an she said- well he wont! LOL they dont go for that! After he moved out her insurance went down by almost 65%.....
Oh how I dread the teenage years!~
Brandy