As a first timer testing out a DVC, (rented points and assure you we didn't trash the place, haha). I must say THE ROOM, THE ROOM, THE GLORIOUS EXTRA ROOM!!! Including the WASHER AND DRYER!! WHEEE!!! I've never been so happy to do laundry, LOL. With all the airlines' extra fees and restrictions, it made it easier to pack "light". Coming back w/all the extra souvenirs, a different story, haha. And w/the nightmare that was our travel back thanks to Delta/Atlanta's freak storm, at least I didn't come home to a mountain of laundry.
2 things I thought I'd miss were mousekeeping and being removed from the main hotel. I was wrong. With all the extra room, we were able to stay tidy and not feel on top of one another. Plus not having to worry about the intrusion. And while I can't speak for other resorts, at VWL, the villas were so quiet, you almost wondered if anyone else was there. Considering the Christmas crowds, it was a very nice change. But still cozy w/the tree and fireplaces.
However, free dining would have been nice. I went ahead and purchased a dining plan because I wasn't sure how comfortable I was going to be w/ordering groceries and such. I will say that will probably be the last time I purchase the dining plan. You guys are right, it is ruining things. They have inflated the prices beyond belief and even paying the gratuity became quite steep. From now on, I'll either get it for free w/a regular room or get a villa and use the kitchen. The dining plan is only a "deal" if it's "free" IMO.