Is it for a girl or boy? If it is for a girl, DD(5) would suggest Olivia or Fancy Nancy. She has loved those since she was 2. For a boy or girl, you can never go wrong with Peter Pan- you can find some really nice books of it, both Disney and non-Disney (DD would tell you to get the Disney version!). DD's absolute favorites currently, are storybooks- books with multiple stories in them. She loves starting at the front of a storybook and reading one a night until the end of the book. She is currently big on Disney's Happily Ever After Stories. For a boy (or girl as DD likes it), Disney's adventure stories might be fun. For a girl, DD would tell you that Cinderella is also a good one. She also has a non-Disney book of fairy tales that she loves.