I just have to add my two cents.
Prior to our wedding, I fell in love with an Ethan Allen bedroom set. We then bought it shortly after our marriage. It is a Georgian Court poster bed, cherrywood. Twenty-seven years and three moves later, it is still in great condition and I still love it. We did have glass tops custom made for nightstands and dressers. That has helped over the years to protect from makup and water stains and such.
We have Ethan Allen living room furniture and our son's bedroom is Ethan Allen. We told him he will take that set with him when he leaves us.
We recently bought a dining room set, unfortunately, it's not Ethan Allen. I cannot justify spending the amount of money they want for a room that does not get used every day.
I say go for it! Our bedroom set has only increased in value, both monetarily and sentimentally. Don't shortchange yourself. You deserve it.
Oh - and as far as experiences....I had them come because of some problem with the couch and then also the loveseat. They came promptly and efficiently took care of the problems (loose buttons both times). This was a few years after we owned the furniture. I believe it is a 5-year warranty.
And just prior to getting ready to hit the *POST* button, I just recalled that my DH's chest of drawers had a problem when we first got it. There was a slight gap between the top and the chest. EA came and replaced the top, no charge, no problem.