Eastern on the Fantasy, or southern on the Magic

[amyshell]

Sooo i'm trying to decide if we should book an Eastern Caribbean on the Fantasy ( just did the Western in Sept 2015 and LOVED it!!) as we were planning..

or the Southern Caribbean on the Magic for April 2017..

April is better for us than January.. so the pricing works out to be a wash with airfare... though hotel will most likely be more $ in San Juan than Orlando..

What would you do?? What have you done?? what did you like better?

 

[mom4fun]

Sooo i'm trying to decide if we should book an Eastern Caribbean on the Fantasy ( just did the Western in Sept 2015 and LOVED it!!) as we were planning..

or the Southern Caribbean on the Magic for April 2017..

April is better for us than January.. so the pricing works out to be a wash with airfare... though hotel will most likely be more $ in San Juan than Orlando..

What would you do?? What have you done?? what did you like better?

Me personally would do the southern, if I had the opportunity. That is a unique itinerary and you don't know how long it will last. The eastern would be great too but you will have plenty of opportunities to do that one.

 

[dclpluto]

You said April is a good month for you and if your not doing Disney world go for the southern Caribbean.

 

[Disneybridewifemama]

We just booked the southern on the magic in april of 2017. Such a unique itinerary, couldn't pass it up!

 

[ACDSNY]

We loved the Southern on the Magic Oct. 2014 and would do it again if I could. Depending on what you do your excursion costs can add up.

 

[darkwing818]

Me personally would do the southern, if I had the opportunity. That is a unique itinerary and you don't know how long it will last. The eastern would be great too but you will have plenty of opportunities to do that one.

One more vote for Southern . We love the Eastern, but it will always be around.