I agree 100% with everything you said. My parents and I also order to tomato soup everytime we go there and even though the price went up, we think it's still worth it.I personally think that the Earl of Sandwich is one of the best bargains to be had at DTD. The food is fresh and fast, but also economical by WDW standards.
We always look forward to their tomato soup ... however, I noticed the price went from $0.99 last year to $1.99 this year. Very good, though.
It is counter service with inside and outside tables.