WIcruizer said:
I've had all three.
Company car- Company pays for insurance, car is in company's name.
Allowance or Mileage- Car is YOURS, in your name, you pay insurance. It usually is a separate check.
I have had all three also. I prefer the company car. I am now on Allowance. I hate it. They tell us how much our car has to retail for, how many miles it can have on it, how much insurance we have to carry and what year the car can be. The amount we recieve is no where near what it takes to cover 75% of these cost. (they assume you will use the car 25% for personal use)
In the good ole days, you could pick a company car from the book ( I usually went with a Camry) or you could take a flat car allowance of $600 a month and drive what you wanted and both options came with an unlimited gas card.
Those days are gone and now you can only get the car allowance which is 1/2 of what it use to be, we have to have newer cars, less milage on them, more insurance and our gas card has a limit which usually only last for 3 weeks before it runs out. We also drive double the miles we use to.
We get a check from the company that monitors the cars twice a month. DH works for a different company but has the same car company and he gets his check once a month.
We are at a crossroad as to what to do this year. His car will be out of compliance next month, but mine has another year. We can flip-flop our cars, but we use mine for the family car and I have a nicer car. I don't want to use DHs car as our family car because its not as nice, and he doesn't keep his as clean as mine. His is usually so full of signs and displays that nobody can ride in it. I just really hate to buy another car.