Interesting question... how to compare? I LOVED the Swan for it's location, service, and using points and cash!
I adored the BWV because it was BEAUTIFUL and we had a 1-BDRM, 2 bath, with kitchen, living room/ dining room, and laundry! Lots of space and a great pool... This was my DD14's fave!
I also loved the theming and grand style of the WL! How to choose?
If I had to pick, it would come down to value... the SWAN has the best value.
For extra space and if I received a great deal on renting DVC points, I would be back at the BWV in a heartbeat!
Choosing WL would also depend on receiving a great discount, since it had the smallest rooms and we are a family of 5! (That being said, we are staying at the VWL just before Thanksgiving in a studio!)